“What A Terrible World, What A Beautiful World” Not Living Up to The Decemberists’ Potential

decemberists album

The Decemberists form an ironic purgatory throughout their new album, “What A Terrible World, What A Beautiful World.” The band’s signature whimsical, folksy attitude is still apparent, yet it lacks a depth shown in their previous work. “What A Terrible World, What A Beautiful World” exhibits a safe middle ground for the Decemberists.

The group’s style in their new album is carefree and laid-back. While it does not meet the standards of the band’s past work, the Decemberists still manage to uphold a pleasant array of hits, ones with a more relaxed, light-hearted tone that any listener will find enjoyable.

The Decemberists began their journey as an indie folk rock band from Portland, Oregon. Members Colin Meloy, Chris Funk, Jenny Conlee, Nate Query, and John Moen self-released their debut EP, “5 songs,” in 2001. Their lyrics often focus on historical events and/or folklore while their live performances are known for their eclectic, entertaining style. The band has produced 7 albums since their first EP, including the favorite “Picaresque” and “Hazards of Love,” an hour and a half long album originally intended to be a staged musical.

“What a Terrible World, What A Beautiful World” includes many upbeat singles. “A Beginning Song” sets the albums tone with casual sincerity, and “Anti-Summersong” is another light-hearted tune, a response to their old hit “Summersong,” but with a revamped style. “The Wrong Year” is also a catchy single, in fact, it is one of the best on the album. It explains a classic tale of love’s difficulties through sincere lyrics and seamless instrumentals. The track is indicative of an overall theme of smooth simplicity throughout the album, being far less energetic than the band’s old work and more traditional indie folk bands.

Although still an enjoyable listen, “What a Terrible World, What A Beautiful World” strays quite far away from the band’s originality. Songs such as “The Singer Addresses His Audience” and “Till the Water’s All Long” lack the spunk and creativity seen throughout the Decemberists’ history. It feels as if the band is taking the notion of maturity to justify some of their blander songs on the album.

Despite this, The Decemberists are still able to create a handful of light, likeable songs. Though the group has unfortunately diverted a bit from their old originality, losing some personality in the process, “What a Terrible World, What A Beautiful World” is an album worth listening to.

“What A Terrible World, What a Beautiful World” is now available digitially and in retail for $9.99.


Leave a comment